Book Review: That’s a Great Question, I’d Love to Tell You by Elyse Myers
As a TikTok aficionado, I’ve adored Elyse Myers’ presence on the platform. Her stories are dripping with sweetness and genuine warmth, offering a welcome reprieve from the often murky waters of social media. So, when I heard she was releasing a book, it felt like a no-brainer—I had to dive in. But what followed was a journey decidedly different than I expected, leading to some surprising reflections.
Elyse’s collection of personal anecdotes aims to share slices of her life, but I quickly found myself grappling with an overwhelming sense of disconnection. While her stories are undoubtedly relatable, they often read like unfiltered stream-of-consciousness rather than crafted narratives. This made for a reading experience that felt more meandering than intentional. I often longed for the depth and nuanced reflection that could elevate these snippets into fully formed experiences.
The early chapters struck me as particularly rough. For instance, one story revolves around a convoluted dialogue about her best friend’s feelings for her. Instead of a quick, poignant moment of realization, I found myself wading through pages of back-and-forth assurances that seemed to linger on the surface. It left me feeling impatient, yearning for more narrative structure and introspection. In embracing the imperfections of real life, Elyse seems to overlook the artistry in storytelling. Every memorable tale holds emotion and insight, and I often felt robbed of those critical elements.
Let’s talk style for a moment. While her TikTok tales thrive on authenticity, translating them to the page revealed cracks where editing could have brought polish. Moments that should elicit gut feelings felt flat and unexamined. I found myself wishing for a guiding voice that would connect the dots—something that could draw me closer into her emotional landscape rather than leave me at the periphery. It’s almost as if I was simply skimming surface, catching glimpses but never quite diving in deep.
Elyse does have an innate charm that shines through her writing; her enthusiasm is palpable, but it sometimes clashes with the need for structure. My instinct tells me that the audiobook version, in which Elyse narrates her own stories, might deliver a different experience altogether. The cadence of her voice could bring the rawness to life, allowing listeners to truly feel the emotions behind her words in a way the written page didn’t capture for me.
Despite my frustrations, I’d recommend this book to those who’ve cherished Elyse’s TikTok presence. If you’re drawn to spontaneous honesty and the casual storytelling style she embodies, you might find joy in this collection of experiences. However, if you’re looking for a polished memoir that dives deep into life’s complexities, you might leave feeling a bit unsettled, much like I did.
Ultimately, reading That’s a Great Question, I’d Love to Tell You was an exercise in patience and reflection. While I learned little about Elyse herself, it did inspire an introspection about the intricacies of storytelling and the craft of writing. It left me wishing for a tighter weave and greater emotional resonance—but isn’t that part of the beauty of literature? Each book holds a mirror to the reader’s own expectations and experiences.
Discover more about That’s a Great Question, I’d Love to Tell You on GoodReads >>