Review of The Best of Friends by Lucinda Berry
As a mother of two young boys, the premise of Lucinda Berry’s The Best of Friends struck a deep chord with me. The notion that one’s worst fears could unfold amidst a night of innocent fun sent shivers down my spine. When I learned that Berry, known for her gripping thrillers, was diving into the complexities of friendship and parenthood paired with a disturbing tragedy, I was both intrigued and apprehensive. But as I flipped through the pages, I couldn’t help but wonder — could this novel measure up to the emotional impact it promised?
The story centers on Kendra, Dani, and Lindsey — three friends bonded since childhood, now navigating the turbulent waters of motherhood. After an unexpected night of partying, their lives are irrevocably altered when a horrific accident involving their teenage boys leaves one dead, another in a coma, and a third lost in silence. It’s a premise that is undoubtedly chilling, and that initial sense of dread is heightened with Berry’s dramatic prologue. You’re thrust into Kendra’s panic, feeling that gut-wrenching fear seep through the pages.
Yet, amidst the turmoil lies a perplexing narrative structure that left me yearning for clarity. The alternating viewpoints among the three mothers, while promising juicy insights, quickly turned messy. Trying to keep track of Kendra, Dani, and Lindsey felt like deciphering a riddle without enough clues. Their voices often blurred, transforming them into one indistinct character rather than three individuals bursting with secrets and complexities. This was disappointing; digging into their distinct personalities could have deepened the emotional stakes surrounding their trauma.
Berry’s writing style leans towards the simplistic, which unfortunately doesn’t lend itself well to a story fraught with emotional weight. Many themes, such as hidden truths and personal struggles, linger tantalizingly in the background but remain frustratingly underdeveloped. For instance, the introduction of an eating disorder late in the narrative felt jarring and unaddressed — an unnecessary shock tactic more than a meaningful exploration. It was as if hints at deeper issues were dropped like breadcrumbs, ultimately leading nowhere.
While the pacing has moments of gripping tension, the slow unraveling of secrets often felt tedious. I found myself longing for a stronger reveal, but by the time the climax unfolded, it came off as anti-climactic, offering little in the way of satisfaction or closure. The epilogue, in particular, left me shaking my head. I couldn’t shake the feeling of disappointment that hung in the air, craving a more thorough tying together of loose ends.
Despite these shortcomings, I managed to remain invested in the story, as Berry’s knack for tension kept me turning pages. I would recommend The Best of Friends to those who enjoy light thrillers and might be drawn in by a premise that raises pivotal questions about friendships and choices. However, I caution fellow parents with young children — the emotional weight and subject matter can be heavy and unsettling.
In summary, The Best of Friends offers a compelling premise with moments of engaging tension, but struggles under the weight of its ambitions: it’s like a rollercoaster that never quite satisfies its thrilling ascent. As I close the book, I find myself reflecting on the delicate balance of friendships and the harrowing experiences of motherhood, realizing that while not every story resonates equally, each reading experience holds its own significance.
For more of my musings on books and their layers, be sure to visit Bantering Books for all my latest reviews!