A Dive into Nate Bargatze’s “Big Dumb Eyes: Stories from a Simpler Mind”
When I first picked up Nate Bargatze’s debut collection, Big Dumb Eyes: Stories from a Simpler Mind, I felt a pull—not just from the eye-catching title, but from the promise of a different kind of narrative. In a world drenched in complexity and heavy themes, the idea of celebrating the humorous threads woven into everyday life intrigued me. After all, what could be better than a good laugh from someone who feels like a friend you can relate to?
Bargatze’s comedic genius shines through as he mines humor from his "simpler mind." The tales he shares about his life—from the trials of maintaining his teenage car, “Old Blue,” to his bizarre escapades in a Chicago basement—are delightful nuggets of joy. His ability to transform ordinary experiences into laugh-out-loud moments feels like sitting down with him at a local diner, where he holds court with anecdotes that drift in and out of laughter. I found myself chuckling over memories of accompanying my own family on whimsical adventures, proving that sometimes, laughter is the most universal language.
One of the standout qualities of Big Dumb Eyes is its unabashed embrace of the Southern perspective. Bargatze’s reflections on his hometown in Tennessee were particularly nostalgic. Describing the sheer chaos that ensues during a rare snowfall—where half an inch sends the entire town sledding until it turns to mud—made me reminisce about my own childhood antics. His father, an eccentric character and professional clown, adds a quirky layer to his family dynamics. I especially appreciated the sibling rivalry that conveys both affection and competition. There’s something innately funny about recounting how “I’m three years older than Derek, so he was literally born in second place”—and it’s a reminder of the playful rivalry many can relate to.
Bargatze’s writing style is refreshingly conversational, capturing the essence of his stand-up persona: straightforward yet rich with humor. His self-awareness, especially regarding his academic struggles, resonates deeply. I particularly loved the line, “You can read this book anywhere or any way you want.” It creates an inviting atmosphere that encourages casual reading—because let’s face it, who hasn’t read a book upside down at some point?
Yet, while the collection is brimming with playful anecdotes and humor, it does have its pitfalls. Some stories felt a tad underdeveloped, with abrupt endings that left me wanting more. This loose structure, though, oddly mirrors the carefree nature of a chat with a friend, where thoughts drift in and out without a rigid agenda.
Ultimately, Big Dumb Eyes may not deliver the profound reflections that some memoirs do. Yet, in this simplicity lies its value. Bargatze provides a heartwarming, entertaining perspective that invites us to take joy in the mundane.
If you’re a fan of light-hearted humor infused with relatable familial dynamics—or if you just need a good laugh after a long day—this book is an enjoyable read. It lifted my spirits and reminded me that sometimes, the truest joys come from the simplest stories. For those yearning for a slice of life that’s genuine and humorous, Nate Bargatze’s Big Dumb Eyes might just be the book you didn’t know you were looking for.
Discover more about Big Dumb Eyes: Stories from a Simpler Mind on GoodReads >>